I’ve been
noticing more and more that people are asking me about my opinion on red
meat. Or have I heard about this study
or that study “proving” that red meat is bad for you, or did I know that red
meat is linked to this or that cancer or disease? I haven’t looked into these studies at that
time, but I decided I probably should, as this goes against everything about my
new way of eating and living. But
hearing what I’ve been hearing was definitely not resonating with me, and I had
a funny feeling some of these “studies” could have a flaw or two, and they
could all be leading to another dangerous health fad like the low-fat craze
started in the 80s (that only led to more disease and obesity…). But I didn’t want to discredit it until I
read more for myself.
The vegetarian lifestyle has caught my interest a time or
two in the past, back when I was exploring different diets and lifestyles in my
attempt to get healthier. I know how
plenty of fruits and vegetables are not only good for you but
necessary for good health. I’ve gone a few weeks to a month without
eating meat, to see if I’d notice a difference.
I didn’t feel the greatest… but that was before I learned what carbs and
sugars do to the body, and I certainly wasn’t avoiding breads and pastas at the
time like I am now. So I don’t know, I
won’t knock the vegetarian lifestyle – to each his own – but I’m not sure I
feel okay about the omnivorous lifestyle getting knocked. Since I’ve been following a more Paleo way of
eating (and I’m not strict, by any means, but I do my best) and learning more
about that lifestyle, it just makes more and more sense to me. It’s balanced, first of all, with lots of vegetables,
fruits, meats, nuts and seeds, and healthy fats and oils. It also takes us back to our roots. Simply put, it’s the “caveman” diet. What did we eat before there was industry and
agriculture interfering with everything?
We existed for thousands of years living off the land – that meant
gathering vegetables, fruits, nuts, seeds, roots, berries, etc., and also
hunting for animals for their meat. And
in wintertime, that meat was critical to our survival. If meat leads to all these cancers and
diseases, wouldn’t the human race have been wiped out long ago?
Since I’ve been following this lifestyle more closely, I’ve
been feeling amazing. I can think
clearer, I feel stronger, I just feel, overall,
good. I know most of that is
because I’ve been avoiding bad carbs like breads and pastas. But I
have
been eating meat...
Now, I will say one thing… processed meats and meats from
animals that had not-so-healthy lifestyles probably aren’t the best to
consume. I truly believe they’re
not. So many animals are not fed
healthy, natural, balanced diets; they’re injected with steroids, artificial
growth hormones, and too many medications, and all that gunk gets stored in
their fat cells and muscle tissue. Which
is what we then eat. Yuck. What are all those residual steroids,
artificial growth hormones, and medications going to do to OUR cells? Lead to all the cancers and diseases that red
meat is blamed for, I bet! Consuming the
meat of animals that ate the grasses and plants in their natural diet is
probably a better idea than eating those that were injected with unnecessary
junk that really only serves to make them more profitable to the farmer. That’s what the cavemen were eating, after
all, and the human race survived that era!
There are a lot of studies that demonize red meat… Here’s a
link to one of them that I’ll pick at for now:
http://archinte.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=1134845
It’s basically saying that the data was gathered by food
frequency questionnaires, so people had to chart what they remembered eating
over the past two years… I’m lucky to remember what I ate for lunch a week ago,
soooo… Anyway. The study groups weren’t very well controlled
either. Factors weren’t taken into
account like the subjects already being overweight, smokers, drinkers, or
sedentary, which that alone can bring about risk factors for your overall
health. And were these people eating
grass-fed meat…? Here’s some more info
on that topic: The beef from corn-fed cows can have as much as 50 times more
omega-6 fatty acids than grass-fed cows. Too much omega-6 in the diet is known
to promote inflammation and oxidation in the body, which, *drumroll*, leads to
heart disease and cancer. Hmmm… But that bit of info was excluded from the
studies. I think a lot of the anti-red
meat studies were conducted without paying attention to these facts.
But enough about those claims and studies that make red meat
seem deadly. Let’s focus on the proof of
WHY humans ARE omnivores. The evidence
is a little more sound here, and isn’t generated from faulty “studies” but
rather historical, archeological, and physiological evidence. Our stomachs
produce hydrochloric acid, which herbivores do not produce, and our pancreas
can produce a large array of digestive enzymes to break down a wide range of
foods, from vegetable to animal. The
teeth in our skulls contain both teeth for tearing meat and teeth for chewing
vegetables, and have been that way since the dawn of our evolution.
According to anatomist and primatologist John McArdle (who,
believe it or not, happens to be a vegetarian himself) expects we would have a
specialized colon, specialized teeth and a stomach that doesn’t have a
generalized pH for digesting meat if we were designed to be strict
vegetarians. That isn’t our case
though. We also have a low synthesis
rate of DHA (a fatty acid) and taurine, which suggests that our ancestors
required animal foods for these nutrients.
Vitamin B12 is another nutrient that is essential for our development
but only found in meats. Even in
The China Study
(a vegetarian bible), Dr. T. Collin Campbell recommended that the Chinese
village people in his study eating a vegetarian/vegan diet take a B12 supplement. If vegetarianism were how our bodies are
designed to eat, we wouldn’t
need
supplementation then, would we? Also,
from what I understand, “animal-protein” was a lump category including not only
meat but milk as well. Most of the
diseases contracted by the villagers in the animal-protein-consumption category
were linked back to casein, a protein in
milk,
not red meat. And I do support avoiding
dairy (although I do have trouble with avoiding it myself… I love me some
cheese… but someday I hope to eliminate it) – we happen to be the only mammals
that consume other mammals’ milk, and I do find that a bit strange… But even when I try to look past that, just
knowing the processing most milk goes through from its raw state to its state
in the carton at the grocery store is a bit disturbing… I have way more researching to do on this
subject, though, so stay tuned in the future when I decide to write an article
about dairy! Let’s get back to the topic
at hand, though.
So what about protein? Protein is found in not only meats and eggs
but in beans, nuts, and grains as well.
So you should be fine on protein if you’re not eating meat, right? Well, here’s the thing about protein: it’s a
chemical made up of chains of amino acids, and they form all animal tissue –
muscle, bone, everything. They transport
and store minerals and oxygen. They are
required for motion. They are needed for
body structure, for blood clotting, for immune system strength, for hormone
production in cells, for enzymes (which are also proteins) to do their jobs in
chemical reactions in the body. It’s
needed for good energy, for blood sugar stability, and bowel function
assistance. Protein is fuel. As I said before, proteins are made up of
amino acids. Our bodies require around
22 amino acids, and we
need to consume around 10 to 12 of them – those are
essential amino acids, and the rest can be manufactured from those essential
ones. Some protein foods contain all the
essential amino acids, and these are called complete proteins. These are mainly meat, poultry, and
eggs. Grains and beans are considered
incomplete proteins, but, from what I’ve read, in the right combinations they
can create complete proteins, making vegetarianism doable for some people. Some foods are much more balanced in
essential amino acids, and a food with good balance has what’s considered a
higher biological quality. Egg protein
is the highest, and meat protein is the second highest in biological quality.
So, all that being said and considered, I’m not going to put
much stock in all these “studies” claiming that red meat is going to kill
us. We are clearly designed to eat it as
well as vegetation, and so long as we eat responsibly (not consuming processed meats
or meats from animals that led unnatural lifestyles), we’ll be just fine. Eating vegetarian is more of an ethical
choice rather than a necessary diet for humans, and I have no problem with
that, so long as you’re making sure your body is getting all the necessary
nutrients it needs to grow and progress.
It’s definitely a humanitarian move to eat vegetarian, especially with
all the terrible conditions our food animals have to deal with, and then in
turn we have to consume… But
my ethical choice is to follow in my
ancestors’ footsteps, eat what God or Nature or whatever you believe in
provides us, and support the farmers that care for our food animals in a
humanitarian way (or, in my case, go hunting!).
And on another hand, I also believe every individual is different – body
chemistry, ethnic background, and lifestyle are all factors in how your body
responds to what you consume. Perhaps
some people’s body chemistries require more protein than others, or protein
from various sources, or some need more vegetables than fruit, or more fruit
than vegetables… I don’t know, I’ll have to look into that more! But, no matter what lifestyle you follow or
choose, do your best to eat clean – as I’ve said before and I’ll continue to
say, avoiding the chemicals that find their way into both meats and produce and
eating clean, grass-fed meats and organic, non-GMO and pesticide-free produce
will do your body a huge favor, both now and in the long run.
If you want to read more, this link has some good food for thought:
http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2011/01/08/chris-masterjohn-criticism-of-the-china-study.aspx
Sources:
http://robbwolf.com/2012/03/14/red-meat-part-healthy-diet/
http://institutefornaturalhealing.com/2012/03/five-reasons-why-red-meat-is-still-good-for-you/
http://rense.com/general20/meant.htm
http://www.drlwilson.com/articles/protein.htm